Nationalism is not patriotism. It is the hijacking of a primal instinct that once ensured survival. The human need to belong evolved in small tribes where loyalty meant life. Modern nationalism exploits that same emotional machinery, but for power, obedience, and war. It takes what was natural and turns it into a political weapon.
The evolution of belonging
Humans survived because they bonded. Early groups shared food, warned each other of predators, and cared for their wounded. Belonging was not ideology. It was necessity. The brain evolved to reward inclusion and to punish isolation.
But as societies grew, that instinct outlived its purpose. The modern state offered an illusion of kinship. It replaced family ties with symbols and slogans. People began to feel loyalty toward flags, not relatives. The emotional circuitry stayed the same, but the object of devotion changed.
From tribe to nation
Tribes relied on trust. Nations rely on imagination. A tribe was built from faces. A nation is built from myths. Propaganda, education, and ritual turned abstract populations into imagined families.
Schools taught children who their enemies were. Governments taught citizens what they must love. Nationalism promised unity but demanded obedience. Questioning the myth became betrayal. Obedience became virtue.
In Russia, this transformation is extreme. Loyalty to the “Motherland” is sacred. The state equates love of the country with loyalty to its rulers. Dissent is treason. The myth of an eternal, besieged Russia keeps people obedient. Enemies are always at the gate—real or imagined. The system feeds on fear, and every generation grows up convinced that defending the homeland means defending the regime.
In the United States, nationalism takes a different mask. It appears as freedom, destiny, and divine blessing. The myth of being “chosen” keeps the country convinced of its moral superiority. The flag replaces the cross, and military might replaces faith. Americans are taught that their way of life must spread, even through bombs. Patriotism becomes a tool for foreign wars and domestic silence.
Emotional engineering through symbols
Every flag, hymn, and monument exists for one purpose: to trigger loyalty without logic. The brain responds to rhythm, color, and repetition. Nationalists understand this better than scientists.
Ceremonies, holidays, and public rituals transform emotion into discipline. People do not march for truth. They march for belonging. National symbols create a sense of sacredness that reason cannot touch.
Russia uses parades to show unity—tanks, flags, and portraits of past heroes. The United States uses fireworks, pledges, and military flyovers. The method is the same. Emotion replaces thought. People cry for colors, not for causes.
The fear of exclusion
In prehistoric times, isolation meant death. Rejection from the group cut off access to food and protection. That fear still lives inside every human brain.
Nationalism exploits it. It defines outsiders as dangerous, immoral, or subhuman. The “us versus them” divide releases adrenaline and shuts down empathy. People who dissent are branded as traitors. Obedience becomes the only path to safety.
This emotional mechanism explains why crowds cheer wars they never started. Russians accept the invasion of Ukraine because opposing it means social death. Americans accepted the invasion of Iraq because questioning it meant being “unpatriotic.” The same instinct drives both societies—fear of exclusion disguised as loyalty.
The illusion of moral superiority
Every nationalist believes their group is morally superior. That illusion turns belonging into righteousness. It divides the world into good and evil, civilized and barbaric, chosen and damned.
This moral fiction fuels hatred. It makes killing feel noble. It makes cruelty look like justice. Empathy shrinks to fit the borders of the map. Those inside are human. Those outside are not.
Both Russia and the United States use this illusion. Moscow claims to fight Western corruption. Washington claims to spread freedom. Each side frames itself as savior and the other as villain. In the end, both justify violence through self-deception.
The war machine
Nationalism and war are twins. One prepares the mind; the other spills the blood. Before soldiers die, their emotions are trained to obey. Propaganda paints violence as virtue and self-sacrifice as glory.
In Russia, television glorifies fallen soldiers as martyrs. Mothers are told their sons died “for the homeland.” In the United States, medals and flag-draped coffins serve the same purpose. Dying for an idea feels noble when the idea is sacred.
From the trenches of World War I to the deserts of Iraq and the fields of Ukraine, every war begins with a story of belonging. People fight not for resources but for myths. The flag becomes a god that demands offerings.
The tragedy is that both sides believe the same story. Each thinks it defends peace. Each believes it fights evil. But in truth, they die for the same illusion—that killing strangers somehow protects the tribe.
The economic and political beneficiaries
Elites gain the most from collective loyalty. Governments rally support by inventing threats. Corporations profit from weapons and reconstruction. The masses provide the blood.
Nationalism distracts from inequality. It channels frustration toward foreigners instead of the powerful. The myth of unity hides class conflict. Workers who should stand together instead fight each other.
Both Moscow and Washington have mastered this diversion. The Russian oligarchs and the American military-industrial complex depend on it. The people wave flags. The powerful count profits.
Modern technologies of belonging
The internet revived tribalism. Algorithms reward anger, outrage, and moral certainty. Online movements mimic religion—shared language, symbols, and rituals. Social networks become digital nations.
Nationalism now spreads faster than ever. It no longer needs flags; hashtags are enough. Russian propaganda floods its networks with “patriotic” narratives. American media does the same from the opposite side. The instinct for belonging that once built families now builds echo chambers. The tribe is eternal, just modernized.
The global paradox
Humanity faces global problems—climate change, migration, pandemics—that no nation can solve alone. Yet nationalism keeps people divided. The instinct for belonging, once vital, now blocks cooperation.
Evolution gave humans empathy, but not for billions. It prepared us for tribes, not planets. Nationalism exploits that evolutionary mismatch. It weaponizes emotions designed for small groups and turns them against humanity itself.
The way forward
The solution is not to erase belonging but to redefine it. People must learn to belong to truth, not to tribes. Global empathy must replace patriotic emotion. Cooperation must be built on shared humanity, not shared myths.
Education must teach how belonging works—how it manipulates fear, love, and identity. Once people see through the illusion, they cannot be controlled by it.
Human evolution gave us loyalty for survival. Nationalism turned it into obedience for power. It is time to reclaim it. True belonging does not come from flags. It comes from understanding.
Leave a Reply