Why the Turkey pardon is illogical

Every year, the U.S. president stands beside a turkey. Cameras flash. Jokes are made. And then, the bird is “pardoned.” One animal, spared from slaughter.

On the surface, it looks symbolic. It feels moral. The gesture says: this life matters. That even a turkey deserves mercy. The public nods. The media smiles.

But as soon as the scene ends, we return to carving knives. Within hours, 46 million turkeys are cooked, cut, and consumed.

If its life matters, then we are monsters

So what are we doing?

If we pardon one because its life is precious, then killing the rest must be evil. There is no way around it. The logic is brutal, and it stares back at us.

You cannot elevate a single life while erasing millions. If the turkey’s life truly matters, then what does that say about Thanksgiving dinner?

Either the ceremony is sincere—and we are monsters. Or it is not sincere at all.

But the harder truth: Maybe their life does not matter

Let us go deeper. Maybe the real contradiction is not between the pardon and the slaughter. Maybe the problem is how we misunderstand the animal itself.

Because perhaps its life does not matter. Not in the way we assume.

Turkeys do not reason. They do not plan or reflect. They do not experience love, fear, joy, or sorrow as we do. Their emotions exist, but only as flashes—reactions to pain, hunger, and noise. Not layered, not rich. And not human.

They do not understand mercy; they do not value being spared. They do not know they were chosen.

We project our ethics onto a creature that cannot comprehend them.

Turkey: Only pain: A life not worth living

Even worse, their life is not neutral—it is agony.

From birth, they suffer. Bred to grow too fast. Bones bend. Skin splits. Movement hurts.

They live in filth. They breathe chemicals. Their beaks are sliced. Their wings are broken. There is no comfort. No daylight. No instinct fulfilled.

This is not life. This is error. Mass-produced pain wrapped in feathers.

Pardon? Death is not injustice: It is an end to suffering

And then comes death. The part we are told to pity.

But is it the worst part? Or is it the only moment of peace?

They die quickly. Mechanically. Without reflection. There is no dream to end. No joy to interrupt. Just silence.

We imagine their death is a tragedy. But it is not. Their life was. And their death, in truth, is relief.

Conclusion: A lie covered by a joke

So what is the turkey pardon? It is not morality. It is a lie.

If their life matters, we are savages. If it does not, then we are fools.

We cannot have both. We cannot save one and kill millions without meaninglessness dripping from every word.

The turkey pardon is not a gesture of mercy. It is a ritual of denial. A joke made to hide a wound we never want to look at.

Because deep down, we know the truth: we are not kind. We are not wise, we are not honest. We are simply pretending.


Posted

in

by

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *